fbpx
Ukraine Disaster Relief Notice
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Conferences
  • Social Menu

The Master's Academy International HomepageThe Master's Academy International

Training Church Leaders Worldwide

  • Connect
    • Donate to TMAI
    • Read Field Reports
    • Devotionals
    • Subscribe to Updates
    • Involve Your Church
  • Member Schools
  • About Us
    • Mission and Core Values
    • Our History
    • What We Believe
    • Ministry Distinctives
  • Blog
Donate
January 5, 2018
Article By Chris Burnett

“Contextualization”: The Missionary’s Dirty Word? (Part 2)

In the first post, we looked at a biblical need for contextualization in the missionary endeavor, as well as the growing problem of errant theories of contextualization.  As, we’ve seen, the debate over the sufficiency, inerrancy and authority of Scripture does not trickle down to mission strategy—it fuels it. Contextualizers who operate from a less-than-conservative bibliology often struggle to critically evaluate the theological underpinnings of major church planting trends.

A Good Bad Example

Take, for example, how missional movement strategists Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch treat contextualization, and how they apply it to one strategic situation. They define contextualizaion as follows:

contextualization attempts to communicate the gospel in word and deed and to establish churches in ways that make sense to people within their local cultural context. It is primarily concerned with presenting Christianity in such a way that it meets peoples’ deepest needs and penetrates their worldviews, thus allowing them to follow Christ and remain in their own cultures.[1]

The theorists claim that sound doctrine is only transcendent insofar as it meets the felt needs of undiscerning nonbelievers and accommodates a Christian discipleship, which in some ways remains arm-in-arm with pagan society and culture. The definition pushes the boundary between witness to and participation in the secular world.

Frost and Hirsch apply their theory to the Muslim Insider Movement, as an example of how the missionary’s reach into the dark world may be successfully deepened. This popular contextualization theory calls for public witness to Christ alongside the public celebration of Islamic religious culture. Missional theorists, like Frost and Hirsch, often support a popular contextualization spectrum which would encourage Muslim converts to consider themselves “Jesus-following Muslim Insiders” who regularly participate in mosque fellowship and prayers, to varying degrees of comfort and risk within the target culture.[2] In a place of anti-Trinitarianism and self-righteous legalism, the Insider is encouraged to quietly (secretly) direct his prayers to Jesus so that he would not be banished from the community and so lose his platform for networking with scores of evangelistic contacts.

Those who look through the lens of conservative bibliology find Frost’s and Hirsch’s search for Muslim religious-cultural significance controversial for at least two reasons. First, the exercise of Christian faith must be in accord with sound doctrine regardless of the opinion or outrage of the onlooking world. In the case of the Insider Movement in Islamic contexts, external practice must match the internal Christian belief in the uniqueness of Jesus Christ. It is difficult to perceive how one might Christianize the act of bowing to Allah, when the intent will be singularly perceived as the veneration of a false God. A proper doctrinal appraisal of the Person and work of Jesus is not only irrelevant in the mosque but offensive (Gal 5:11), and thus the secret thoughts of the insider would create great strife if they were actually made known to fellow attendees. If the purpose of insider mosque participation is the eventual verbal proclamation of the gospel, will it not ultimately lead to alienation and potentially violent hostility, as Jesus expected for His disciples?

The exercise of Christian faith must be in accord with sound doctrine regardless of the opinion or outrage of the onlooking world.

Second, western-generated attempts at cultural accommodation often appear based, in part, on an unbiblical fear of man. There is perhaps a tangible pragmatic concern that if the insider does not conduct his Trinitarian worship quietly, he might be violently banished from the community and lose his platform for networking with scores of evangelistic contacts. Such concerns underestimate the serious error of publicly denying the deity of Jesus by association. Rather, they propagate the false notion that witness among Muslims apart from the mosque is either less direct or less efficient. But is time more wasted by publicly witnessing to neighbors and in the marketplace or by secretly bowing to Jesus so as not to be ousted by mosque participants?

Frost and Hirsch have (perhaps unwittingly) upheld Muslim culture and community, inciting local converts to similar sinful fears as the believing-but-not-confessing Jews in John 12:42–43 who would not leave the synagogue community for fear of persecution and banishment by society’s ruling class. Contextualization models only follow a conservative trajectory insofar as they seek to penetrate a culture with the transcendent truth of Scripture in a way which leaves neither room for cultural misinterpretation nor the adoption of false doctrine (syncretism). The continued rejection of man-centered approaches to gospel proclamation is no easy task, but it is the task of the conservative evangelical missionary.

A Better Question

Questions about how the missionary should engage a local context with Scripture seem to float unanswered in a sea of man-centered questions arising from Intercultural Studies Departments across the Western academic world. It is no wonder that after four decades of contextualization research the role of the missionary remains in a perplexing state concerning the attitude toward the use of the Bible in delivering truth to all peoples. Conservative evangelicals are correct that for the most part the wrong questions are being asked.

The Global Church suffers when the Bible is not upheld as its ultimate authority.

The Global Church suffers when the Bible is not upheld as its ultimate authority. How will cultures submit to the authority of the Bible if those who imparted the faith to them do not? Recognizing that contextualization theory influences practice is a first step in the search for better questions and better results, but it is only a half step. Progress in a more biblical direction for the now ubiquitous field of contextualization will require serious conviction by conservative theologians who interact with the theories that shape the next generation of missionary practice. Those who shake their head in disapproval should consider their role in righting the wrong before another wave of poor contextualization theories pass into Global Church strategy. Who will rise up and demand rigid orthodoxy from Christian institutions? Who will plead with the experts to demonstrate more biblically legitimate concern for salvation? And who will labor to overturn bad theory with new and compelling research on how the absolutely sufficient, transcultural Word of God is still accomplishing Christ’s kingdom purposes today? The hope for the future of missiology and the Global Church lies with faithful, conservative evangelicals. May the Lord raise up such men.

[1] In Michael Frost and Alan Hirsch, Shaping of Things to Come—Innovation and Mission for the 21st Century Church (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 2004), 83, with discussion on pp. 82–94.

[2] John Travis, “Must All Muslims Leave ‘Islam’ to Follow Jesus?,” Evangelical Missions Quarterly, 34 no 4 (Oct, 1998): 411–15.

[3] Phil Parshall, “Going Too Far?” in Evangelical Missions Quarterly, 34:3 (Oct, 1998).

[4] In Tim Matheny, Reaching the Arabs—A Felt Need Approach (Pasadena: William Carey Library, 1981), 153.

Original Post Date: July 21, 2017

Post Category
< Prev Post “Contextualization”: The Missionary’s Dirty Word? (Part 1)
How to Write Praises When Low on Praise > Next Post

Email Updates

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

The Master's Academy International
Attn: Accounting
PO Box 846864
Los Angeles, CA 90084-6864
(818) 909-5570
info@tmai.org
Click for Physical Mailing Address
Affiliate Ministries
The Master's Seminary The Master's University Grace to You Grace Community Church
  • Membership Standards
  • Find a Member School
  • Contact Us

TMAI is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt nonprofit organization.

© 2022 The Master's Academy International

Thinking Biblically about Poverty and Spirituality (French)

Growing God’s Way (Spanish)

Intelligent Design (Spanish)

The Gospel of the King (Russian)

Reformation of the Heart (Russian)

Christian Andresen

Q&A Participant
Christian and his wife Sheryl moved back to Germany over twenty years ago and started the European Bible Training Center (EBTC) in Berlin to train up nationals for pastoral and missionary work and strengthen the local churches. As president of the ever-growing EBTC, Christian oversees the school in Berlin and its extensions in Germany, Switzerland and Austria as well as its publishing ministry. He also serves as one of the pastors at Eckstein Gemeinde Berlin, a four-year-old church plant at the heart of Berlin, and is eager to invest in church-planting ministries across Europe through his role as Regional Shepherd at Grace Ministries International. Christian and Sheryl have four wonderful grown-up children and several grandchildren.

 

John MacArthur

Q&A Participant
Dr. John MacArthur is the pastor-teacher of Grace Community Church, as well as an author, conference speaker, chancellor emeritus of The Master’s University and Seminary, and featured teacher with the Grace to You media ministry.

Carlos Montoya  

Q&A Participant
Carlos Montoya is President of Ministerios Evangélicos de Las Americas (MEDA), a TMAI pastoral training center located in Siguatepeque, Honduras. MEDA’s main program is The Seminary for Expository Preaching (SEPE) where its motto is Training men to Preach Christ with Power, Passion and Precision. He also serves as a pastor at Iglesia Bautista Betania. 

He has a bachelor’s degree from the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. He then studied at Dallas Theological Seminary, receiving his MABS in 1989, and married his bride Lori the same year. After several years, Carlos felt the need to study the original languages, leading him to attend The Master’s Seminary, graduating in 1999. The Montoya family moved to Honduras in 2001. He and Lori have 7 children and 5 grandchildren. 

 

Dave Beakley

Q&A Participant
David and his wife Carol were raised in Arizona, and after following David’s career in High Tech manufacturing, the Lord called David to ministry and he graduated from The Master’s Seminary in 2002. Just six weeks after graduating, David, Carol, and their four children were sent out by Grace Community Church as missionaries to South Africa, where David served as a lecturer at Christ Seminary in the city of Polokwane. During that time, David eventually was selected by the nationals to serve as the Academic Dean as well as an elder at Christ Baptist Church. He also earned his PhD at the University of Potchefstroom in 2014. His wife Carol also serves in Christ Baptist Church teaching various women’s Bible Studies and discipling women. The children were all raised in South Africa and are now living as adults in the USA. Currently, David is the Senior Pastor (teaching pastor) of Christ Baptist Church, the Academic Dean of Christ Seminary, teaches various courses in Christ Seminary, and he also serves as the TMAI African Regional Coordinator and the GMI Regional Missions Shepherd for Africa. He and his family have been serving in South Africa for over 18 years.

 

Greg White

Q&A Participant
Greg White was sent out by Grace Community Church in 1992 to serve the Evangelical churches of Ukraine. Over the past 28 years he has had the privilege to be a part of 2 church plants and the start and development of 2 seminaries. Greg is pastor of Grace Bible Church, Chief Academic Officer of Grace Bible Seminary in Kyiv, Ukraine, Regional Pastor of Eurasia for Grace Ministries International and Liaison & Consultant, Eurasia for The Master’s Academy International. Beside his administrative responsibilities, Greg also is a professor in the area of New Testament at Grace Bible Seminary and the European Bible Center, Berlin, Germany. Greg is married to Hue Chon and has 3 grown children and 2 grandchildren who live in Southern California.

Dave Beakley

Q&A Participant
David and his wife Carol were raised in Arizona, and after following David’s career in High Tech manufacturing, the Lord called David to ministry and he graduated from The Master’s Seminary in 2002. Six weeks after graduating, David, Carol, and their four children were sent out by Grace Community Church as missionaries to South Africa. David was eventually selected by South Africans to serve as the Academic Dean of Christ Seminary, as well as an elder at Christ Baptist Church. He then earned his PhD at the University of Potchefstroom in 2014. His wife Carol also serves in Christ Baptist Church teaching various women’s Bible Studies and discipling women. He also serves as the TMAI African Regional Coordinator and the GMI Regional Missions Shepherd for Africa. 

Alexey Prokopenko

Seminar Title | The Gospel of the King: The Influence of the Doctrine of Christ’s Kingship on Various Aspects of Christian Life and Theology
Alexey Prokopenko has served as a professor at Samara Center for Biblical Training since 2007 and as pastor of Transfiguration Baptist Church in Samara, Russia, since 2012. He has earned degrees from Medical University of Samara (MD) and The Master’s Seminary (PhD). Alexey has authored several books in the Russian language, including commentaries on Genesis and Ruth, as well as annotated translations of Proverbs and Ecclesiastes. He currently serves as pastor of a new church plant in his home city. Alexey and his wife Kate have two beautiful children.

Faly Ravoahangy

Seminar Title | Thinking Biblically about Poverty and Spirituality
Faly Ravoahangy, a graduate of The Master’s Seminary currently enrolled in their Doctor of Ministry program, is the founder and Managing Director of Madagascar 3M, a ministry started in 2017, aiming to come alongside the existing structures and to be involved in
identifying, training and equipping men to study, obey and teach God’s Word. Ultimately, Madagascar 3M desires to open a Bible-teaching seminary, focusing on expository preaching, so to develop a new generation of godly church leaders in francophone Africa.

Faly is also part of the eldership team and a teaching pastor at Ankadivato Biblical Baptist Church in Antananarivo, the capital city of Madagascar. He is married to Lily and they are blessed with 5 children.

David Robles

Seminar Title | Growing God’s Way: Biblical Ministry Success
David Robles serves as the teaching pastor of Iglesia Evangelica de Leon and is the founding president of Berea Seminary, Spain. He has a wide teaching and preaching ministry throughout Spain, Europe, Latin America and the USA. David is a graduate of Multnomah Biblical Seminary and The Master´s Seminary. He and his wife, Loida, have three daughters.

Ruben Videira

Seminar Title | Intelligent Design: Why God Agrees with Paul (re: Female Pastors)
Ruben Videira graduated from The Master’s Seminary with his M.Div. in 2011 and Th.M. in 2014. The same year he moved to León, Spain, with his family, to serve at the Evangelical Church of Leon and the Berea Seminary. At the seminary he serves as the Academic Dean and professor of Hermeneutics, Bible Exposition and Theology, and at the church his ministry focuses on preaching and discipling. He has been married to Jenn since 2010, and the Lord has blessed them with Oliver (2013), Eden (2015), Caleb (2016), and Zoe (2018).

 

Premend Choy

Seminar Title | Theological Corruption in the South Pacific: A Biblical Response
Premend Choy lives in Lautoka, Fiji. Born and raised a Hindu, but in his teenage years God worked to bring the life-changing effect of the glorious Gospel through the ministry of Lovu Bible Church. He currently serves as the teaching pastor of Lovu Bible Church and his desire is to see a conservative church planted in every town in Fiji.

Premend also serves as the new president of the College of Theology and Evangelism Fiji [CTEF], which he joined 27 years ago. The ministry is committed to developing godly leaders in Fiji and across Oceania. CTEF was founded by Narayan Nair in 1974. Premend is a graduate of CTEF and The Master´s Seminary. He is married to Ashwin and they are blessed with 2 daughters.

Joshua Mack

Seminar Title | A Case Study from South Africa: Towards a Certain Church
Joshua and his family recently moved back to the United States after serving for 14 years in South Africa, where they planted Living Hope Church, began the African Bible Training Center, and started the
Muphamuzi Baby Home. He now serves as pastor at Cornerstone Bible Church in Fullerton, California, while continuing to mentor teachers at various African Bible Training Centers. He is particularly passionate about providing solid theological resources in under-resourced areas. He is the author of Compasssion: Seeing with Jesus Eyes and the co-author of several other books. He received his M.A. and M.Div from The Master’s University and Seminary, and D.Min from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. 

Nick Kalena

Seminar Title | Biblical Counseling in Europe
Nick Kalena has been serving in Berlin, Germany, for six years. He moved with his wife, Jodi, and their six children from Mission Viejo, CA, in the summer of 2014 to work for the European Bible Training Center. Since then he has been serving in and is now the director of the EBTC’s Biblical Counseling Program. Alongside of EBTC ministry, he joined a church planting team in 2016 that started the Eckstein Gemeinde Berlin. One year later, Nick and the two church planters from the planting team were ordained as elders.  Nick’s ministry focus at the EBTC and at the Eckstein Gemeinde is counseling and discipleship. He enjoys bringing people to God’s Word to help them grow in their knowledge of the Son of God. 

Alexey Kolomiytsev

Seminar Title | Reformation of the Heart
Over the last 30 years, Alexey Kolomiytsev has been involved in pastoral ministry in Russia and other Russian-speaking countries. He has also led Word of Grace Bible Institute for 22 years and has served as senior pastor at Word of Grace Bible Church or the last 18 years. Alexey’s focus in ministry is spreading the influence of expository preaching, as well as preparing preachers in the Russian-speaking world. His wife Tanya has been faithfully supporting him in ministry over the last 35 years.

Jurem Ramos

Seminar Title | My Journey from the Crucifix to the Cross and The Ancient Paths
Lead Pastor of Soli Deo Gloria Christian Church
Davao City, Philippines
Jurem was raised a Catholic, but after high school he changed his beliefs to Hinduism. In 1981 God opened his eyes to realize his errors and his sinfulness, and to believe in Christ. After his conversion, he was again involved in falsehood with the prosperity gospel and the pragmatic philosophy of ministry. The teachings of John MacArthur were one of God’s instruments to correct his false views and to guide him into a more biblical ministry. He is currently the lead pastor of Soli Deo Gloria Church, the administrator of their school ministry, and a teacher of their radio ministry. He and his wife, Ging, have been married for almost 30 years, and they have three children. And last year, he became a happy “Lolo.”

 

Cherif Arif

Seminar Title | The Importance of an Historical/Grammatical Hermeneutic in Egypt
Cherif Arif was born and raised in Cairo, Egypt. He got an MBS from the National Theological College and Graduate School (NTCGS) in Cairo, Egypt; an MDiv. from Maranatha Baptist Seminary, Wisconsin; a ThM from TMS; and is now working on a PhD at TMS. He has served as a professor at NTCGS since 2011, both in Cairo and other locations: Jordan and Lebanon. He is now working on an exegetical/pastoral commentary on the Book of Ecclesiastes in Arabic. He desires to continue serving by equipping pastors and leaders and writing exegetical/theological works in Arabic for the church in the Middle East. “My heart is that many in this area of the world come to the saving faith in our God and Lord Jesus Christ.”

David Zadok

Seminar Title | The Significance of Dispensationalism in Eastern Ministry
David Zadok was born in Israel but grew up in Iran. At the age of 16 he was sent to the USA, due to the Islamic revolution in 1979. In San Diego, California he completed his High School and graduated from San Diego State University with B.A. in computers and business administration. Later he completed his M.A. at Westminster Theological Seminary and Institute of Reformed Baptist Studies. David is also a retired Major; he served in the Israel Defence Forces.  

David pastors over the Grace and Truth congregation in Israel, and has been serving in the same church for 31 years as an elder. He also directs the HaGefen Publishing and is currently working on completing his D.Min studies at The Masters’ Seminary. 

David is married to Esther (Eti), and they have three children.